Earlier this week I wrote about what a promotion actually does to a brand, and after I posted it, I kept thinking about why brands end up there in the first place. That question matters just as much.

‍

I think most brands end up discounting for one reason, and it’s not because the market demanded it or because the competition forced it. It’s because they never gave the market a real reason to pay full price.

‍

I know that sounds blunt, but I've watched it happen enough times to say it confidently.

‍

Here's what I’ve seen happen again and again: A brand launches with a product that truly deserves a premium price point. Perhaps the formulation is better, or the sourcing is more specific, or the founder has credentials that no competitor can match. The brand prices accordingly, but sales come in lower than expected, and within six months they run their first promotion. Then another and another and then comes a permanent markdown. At this point the brand is selling a premium product at a commodity price and wondering why their margins don't work.

‍

The product didn't fail. The brand did.

‍

A price point is not a number you pick or a formula that applies to everyone. It's essentially a claim you make, and like any claim, it has to be earned and proven. The market will pay a premium for a brand that has given it a specific, ownable, credible reason to do so. It will not pay a premium for a brand that looks like every other brand in the category, uses the same language as every other brand in the category, and gives the customer no clear reason to choose it over the one sitting next to it on the shelf.

‍

That's the gap. The product is worth the premium, but the brand hasn't built the foundation to justify it. So the market treats it like a commodity, because that's what the brand is actually communicating.

‍

I've worked with brands with irreplaceable products selling at prices that belonged to commodity brands. Not because the product wasn't worth more. Because the brand hadn't closed the gap between what the product was worth and what it was communicating. The credential that justified the price was buried. The sourcing story that made the formulation defensible was in the third paragraph of the About page. The science that separated it from every competitor was mentioned once in a product description nobody read.

‍

Close the gap first, and the price will justify itself.